As such, its not surprising that such revisionist genre practitioners as Sam Pechinpah and Sergio Leone would eventually follow in his footsteps. No bronze frontier effigies, the Mann-Stewart protagonists are warped brooders negotiating the impending collapse of terrain, body, and mind. Given her lack of options, Gbia and a friend visit a male abortionist, who expects sexual favors in return. And yet theres something particularly modern about its approach to the doomed relationship between infamous bank robber and murderer Jesse James (Brad Pitt) and his Judas-like accomplice, Robert Ford (Casey Affleck). But it was the Coen brothers' wildly successful 2007 movie No Country for Old Menand their celebrated remake of True Gritwhich helped catapult the Western back into popular consciousness. 9. In this revered Western, Ethan Edwards (John Wayne) returns home to Texas after the Civil War. Its to Leones credit that the huge, carefully plotted story isnt whats remembered about the film, which is nothing if not the ultimate culmination of the auteurs genre work. - Runtime: 132 minutes. When U.S. John Wayne, Robert Mitchum, and James Caan star in the story of a gunfighter and a sheriff caught up in a battle between rival ranchers over water. The film, which took seven-and-a-half months to edit, was the first Western ever entered into competition at the Cannes Film Festival. The surreal El Topo follows the quest of a mystical man clad in black, traveling on horseback through the Mexican desert with a naked child. As filmmakers around the planet continue to visit the world of cattle drives and gunfights, we'll keep this list updated with the very best of the West. However, before Ofelia can fulfill her destiny, she must complete three gruesome tasks. - Director: Billy Wilder Audiences loved gun-slinging sheriffs, dashing outlaws, thundering . Greene. Its also one of the most beautiful and human of all American westerns. Schager, Ride Lonesome begins with Randolph Scotts Ben Brigade capturing a young gunman, Billy John (James Best), in thrilling fashion, intending to use the man as bait to lure his older brother, Frank (Lee Van Cleef), who hanged Bens wife so long ago that I almost forgot, into confrontation. Despite being several decades old, this heralded drama simply oozes with perennial primacy, putting show business in its crosshairs and hitting the target with a bulls-eye. The historical American West was more diverse and less male-dominated than the one Hollywood imagined for many years. After starring in a string of popular indie films, actress Greta Gerwig wrote and directed this comedy-drama about a teenage girl who comes of age in Sacramento, California, in the early 2000s. Tessa Thompson and Lily James play estranged sisters struggling to get by in small-town North Dakota. - Metascore: 97 6. Hoppers action scenes are beautiful, worthy of Fuller and Peckinpah, though he also holds such gorgeous violence in contempt, likening it to social pollution. - Director: John Ford 100 best Western films of all time, according to critics. - Director: Martin Scorsese The French movie actress pitched in to help the financially strapped production, contributing her own money and lending her Rolls Royce for carrying props. For decades in America, the most popular movie genre was the Western. - Runtime: 170 minutes. For any other film, landing at #6 on a "best of all time" list would be an honor. Growing up in a broken home, Chiron falls under the wing of a local drug dealer (Mahershala Ali). From there, things only get testier as the preacher settles down and weathers first a disease outbreak, then the racist fury that a local tycoon, Lon Backett (Ed Begley), whips up among the towns out-of-work miners to drive a freed slave, Uncle Famous Prill (Juano Hernandez), off of his property so that the businessman can expand his mine. Ford F250 Bumpside Truck Box - ROUGH but Usable - 1967-1972 - $100 (Graham) Ford F250 Bumpside Truck Box - ROUGH but Usable - 1967-1972. Chuck Norris stars in the film, which served as the basis for his later television series titled Walker, Texas Ranger. Controversial director Michael Haneke puts a couple's decades-long marriage to the test in this slow-moving, intricate work. - Runtime: 75 minutes. The Velvet Underground - The Velvet Underground & Nico. Gripped by a sense of unspoken grief since the accidental death of Huds brother, father and son repeatedly lock horns over Huds boozing, philandering, and general devil-may-care attitude. - Runtime: 116 minutes. You may also like: 20 Top Documentaries About Parenthood, - Director: Alfred Hitchcock Lawless plains where cowboys and Native Americans skirmished, and pioneers battled harsh conditions to seek their fortunes in the great unknown, had already been tamed. Robb, Alejandro Jodorowskys El Topo opens with a passage that could be an existential journey for ones soul or a spoof of a spaghetti western: The bearded, leather-clad gunfighter El Topo (Jodorowsky) and his young son (Brontis Jodorowsky) ride through the desert and into a hamlet of bloodily decimated people and animals. Based on a fairy tale by the Brothers Grimm, the movie follows Snow White as she flees from an evil queen and seeks shelter with a group of highly personable dwarfs. - Metascore: 97 "Jeff" Jefferies, who gets confined to a wheelchair after breaking his leg in an accident. Brown, Rancho Notorious opens with Vern Haskell (Arthur Kennedy) planting a big kiss on his fiance, Beth (Gloria Henry), but this being a Fritz Lang film, its downhill from there for the Wyoming cowpoke. As with 2007s other great American work, David Finchers Zodiac, Dominiks triumph focuses on an iconic criminal from the countrys past, and the way in which that personage, refracted through the medias filter, epitomized our love-hate rapport with fame. Judy Garland leads the cast of the popular family musical. He makes the town funny but retains its barbarism. - Metascore: 98 - Director: Vincente Minnelli All rights reserved. - Metascore: 74 It stars Warren Oates, Emilio Fernandez, Gig Young, and Robert Webber, and Kris Kristofferson appears as a biker. In 1997, Deneke was murdered when 17-year-old Dustin Camp intentionally hit him with his car. When the brothers briefly look upon one another, were primed to remember the first-person shots that opened the film, and to recall the feelings of pursuit that have hounded Willet from the outset. Audiences loved gun-slinging sheriffs, dashing outlaws, thundering . - Runtime: 134 minutes. - Metascore: 96 It won the Palme d'Or at Cannes, among numerous other awards. - Director: Gordon Douglas, Paul Bogart The 10 Best Westerns Of All Time, According To The AFI By Shane Redding Published Nov 30, 2021 AFI's list of the best Westerns of all time features movies led by legends of the genre like John Wayne, Clint Eastwood, and Robert Redford. My lists are not based on my own personal favorites; they are based . The Best Western Movies of All Time, According to Critics and Audiences. - Runtime: 126 minutes. Marlene Dietrich plays a not-to-be-trusted saloon singer. - Runtime: 92 minutes. See if your favorite made the top 100. Jauja is closer in aim to a deconstructionist western, centered on the Danish Captain Dinesen (Viggo Mortensen), a soldier assigned to Argentinas Patagonia region. Fullers debut feature is remarkable for its sophisticated and intuitive treatment of a famed tale of the Old West, viewing Robert Fords (John Ireland) cowardly assassination of his friend and fellow thief Jesse James (Reed Hadley) as a quintessentially gay love story. In the typically larger-than-life figures of Doc Holliday and Wyatt Earp, Stacy Keach and Harris Yulin, respectively, find pitiable smallness, undercutting the icons by emphasizing their callousness and opportunism. - Director: George Stevens Director Burt Kennedy also wrote the movie, which is action-filled with an unexpected ending. While audiences really liked this Richard Linklater film, the critics absolutely adored it. - Director: Kathryn Bigelow Pat Brown. The New York Times movie critic Frank Nugent wrote such an expert review of the work that he was subsequently hired by Fox Studios as a script-doctor. To stay hidden, the musicians disguise themselves as women and join an all-female band. - Director: John Huston ", far from the only critic to feel that way, The Democratic Party Should Set Higher Standards | Opinion, The Democratic Party is Becoming Less Inclusive | Opinion. In that sense, Boettichers works are far closer to the similarly underappreciated chamber westerns of Monte Hellman, where the endless spaces of the American West show an unmistakable tinge of Beckett as men ride in absurdist circles, looking for serenity. - Runtime: 88 minutes. - Runtime: 123 minutes. Books was John Wayne's final film role; he himself died of stomach cancer a few years after the film was released. With its central couple, Karl-Oscar (Max von Sydow) and Kristina (Liv Ullmann), now firmly grounded in the new world, expressionistic, nostalgia-laden flashbacks of their former life back in Sweden perceptively color their current struggle to build a new life and community from the ground up. Stacker compiled the 100 best Western films of all time using data from Metacritic, a site that collects reviews from respected critics and uses them to determine the average rating. Bullets provide the stigmata for the heros nutty crucifixion midway through, and the films second half finds El Topo as a bald-headed holy fool, reborn in a cave full of freaks before emerging into the most corrosive send-up of the western since Godards Wind from the East, a hilariously decadent frontier Sodom where Russian roulette is played in church for miracles. Croce, A mournful modern-day ode to a vanishing way of life, The Lusty Men pits homeward-looking, aging rodeo star Jeff McCloud (Robert Mitchum) against upstart Wes Merritt (Arthur Kennedy), positioning Wess wife, Louise (Susan Hayward), as the upright angle in this acute triangle. Cleavon Little stars as Bart, the newly appointed sheriff, while Gene Wilder plays Jim, an alcoholic who quickly becomes his friend. By capitalizing on the latest 3D technology, the film brought viewers along for the ride, proverbially speaking. - Runtime: 131 minutes. - Runtime: 122 minutes. Accordingly, the film hosts a dizzying array of groundbreaking elements, from the creative camerawork to the unconventional narrative to everything in between. - Metascore: 94 Since then, movie criticism has retained countless core consistencies while evolving to keep pace with the medium itself. Unforgiven (1992) Retired Old West gunslinger William Munny reluctantly takes on one last job, with the help of his old partner Ned Logan and a young man, The "Schofield Kid." 6. - Runtime: 108 minutes. The songs were written and performed by the actors themselves, and Carradine's "I'm Easy" won an Oscar and a Golden Globe. The film was nominated for a number of awards, and recognized as one of the best films of 2007 by numerous critics. Bowen, What is Badlands if not a meditation on the scarcity of identity of a notorious murderous couple mythologized for his charisma and her alleged innocence, and who better to pose such questions than a philosopher? A drunken Doc Holliday (Val Kilmer), when accused of seeing double, says, I have two guns, one for each of you. Wyatt Earp (Kurt Russell), as he pistol-whips Johnny Tyler (Billy Bob Thornton), belts out, You gonna do something? Community. Senator Ranse Stoddard returns to the West to attend a funeral, he is forced to rehash his past, including the truth regarding the killing of an infamous outlaw. Additionally, we picked only. The modern era of computer animation arguably begins with this original classic from 1995. You may also like: 50 Best American War Movies, - Director: Martin Scorsese It was based on a novel of the same name by Akiyuki Nosaka. Hes got a horse. In one key scene, Ray traces the complex web of relations between the characters with a series of sinuous tracking shots, tracing out each strand as the actors cross and re-cross the scene. - Director: Brad Bird The French New Wave masterpiece stars Jeanne Moreau at the center of a love triangle, and the relationship of the threeOskar Werner as Jules and Henri Serre as Jimover 25 years. Black Rock hasnt had any visitors in four years, and this lack of tourism suits bigwig rancher Reno Smith (Robert Ryan) and his thug cohorts Coley (Ernest Borgnine) and Hector (Lee Marvin) just fine, since it allows them to maintain control over a community gripped by guilt over the death of a Japanese farmer named Komoko. The Telegraph's . - Director: Sergei M. Eisenstein This is, after all, the best Western film from the best Western director (John Ford) starring the best Western actor (John Wayne) filmed by . In the punchy Vera Cruz, the goal of transporting a countess (Denise Darcel) and her gold to the titular port city in the Gulf of Mexico sparks various shifts in alliances and perpetual double-crosses between American rejects like ex-Confederate soldier Ben Trane (Gary Cooper) and the sadistic Joe Erin (Burt Lancaster). What scans in the surviving One-Eyed Jacks, however, is a sense of orchestrated chaos and blooming obsession. - Director: Alfonso Cuarn Grace Kelly co-stars. Released: 1956. What follows over the course of 12 years is nothing short of tragic, as Northup and his peers suffer a range of abuses at the hands of an alcoholic slave owner (Michael Fassbender). Under normal. Cooper plays a town sheriff who fails to recruit anyone else to help him confront a gang of vengeful criminals due to arrive in his sweaty desert village on the noon train. - Runtime: 64 minutes. When one of the students comes across a wounded Union corporal, played by Clint Eastwood, the teacher must decide what to do with him. Greene, Released in 1969, the same year as Sam Peckinpahs game-changing revisionist western The Wild Bunch, George Roy Hills Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid ushered in its own quiet revolution of sorts, introducing a playful joie de vivre to the genre that had rarely been seen before. - Runtime: 104 minutes. - Metascore: 77 The Preacher often appears out of nowhere, as if he were a religious miracle, while the mountainous club (Richard Kiel) and Marshall Stockburns (John Russell) silent, identically dressed deputies suggest something out of a stained-glass tableau. In this 1943 thriller, "master of suspense" Alfred Hitchcock tells the story of young Charlotte 'Charlie' Newton (Teresa Wright) who gets a surprise visit from her Uncle Charlie (Joseph Cotten). - Metascore: 66 You may also like: 15 Controversial Oscar Winsand How They've Aged, - Director: Francis Ford Coppola Going further than establishing any sense of truth, Ford exposes the ways that American systems privilege white people. Robb, One-Eyed Jacks is a deeply introspective western, with most of the hallmarks of the genre, thats viscerally eaten up with the alienation of director and star Marlon Brando. - Metascore: 64 In the time since, however, The Manchurian Candidate has garnered appreciation among a wider audience, and the film was even remade in 2004. - Director: Cline Sciamma - Director: Sergio Leone The film is bookended by Stewarts Ransom Stoddard as an old man, telling the story of the man who shot the outlaw Liberty Valance, with Lee Marvin marvelously playing the titular character with beady-eyed menace, snarling his famous opening line from behind a bandana with equal parts authority and venom: Stand and deliver! The film maintains itself as one of the most original western films ever made as Wayne, ever the on-screen hero, becomes a drunk by the third act, and Stewart, ever the scrawny second fiddle, turns out to lead the heroic life. - Runtime: 100 minutes. - Runtime: 122 minutes. Frank and company are violent cowboys, but within the flat Olancha Dune landscape they are, at the very least, recognizably human. Tommy Lee Jones, Javier Bardem, and Josh Brolin star in this Western, which begins when a botched drug deal is interrupted by a hunter. - Runtime: 156 minutes. - Runtime: 103 minutes. For my money, this is Boettichers crowning achievement. - Director: Robert Greene - Runtime: 132 minutes. True to its name, this 2015 drama centers on a couple who have been married for 45 years. - Runtime: 101 minutes. Whats remembered is the blue, uncaring sky cast above a dry, ruthless wasteland of a desert with winds kicking up miniscule storms of red dirt, dust, and debris; the way Charles Bronsons elusive, solemn gunslinger moves that harmonica across his parched lips; and Jills (Claudia Cardinale) near-ritualistic humiliation at the hands of the cackling, diabolical Frank (Henry Fonda). - Director: Sergio Leone - Metascore: 91 - Metascore: 94 - Metascore: 79 - Director: Chlo Zhao Revisionist in the most sobering of ways, The Rider shows the westerns ideals of freedom and manifest destiny completely inverted, as people with diminishing prospects and shrinking horizons are forced to abandon heroism in favour of bare survival. Tony Curtis plays The Great Leslie, Jack Lemmon plays Professor Fate, and Natalie Wood and Peter Falk round out a top-notch comic cast. A Fistful of Dollars is the first film of the spaghetti Western Dollars Trilogy, all directed by Sergio Leone. Like Hellman (or Clint Eastwood, another fan), Boetticher is aware of the conventions of the genrethat, for instance, Ben and Anne will fall for each other sooner or later, or that Ben and Bill will have a showdown. One of the sisters has quit the life of smuggling drugs across the Canadian border, but is drawn back in by a series of family crises. - Runtime: 89 minutes. The sequel to the 1931 film, Frankenstein, features Elsa Lanchester as Mary Shelley and as the iconic Bride with stitches on her face and silver streaks in her towering shock of hair, and Boris Karloff as the Monster. - Director: Ji-woon Kim Like Clint Eastwood, he barely distinguishes the heroes from the villains, but unlike Eastwood, he doesnt make a self-congratulatory show of that basic matter-of-factness. - Metascore: 96 Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here. When Ulzana is eventually killed, tellingly by Ke-Ni-Tay (Jorge Luke), DeBuin insists on a Christian burial. "The 100 Greatest Western Movies of All Time: Including Five You've Never Heard Of" is a fun, opinionated look at the best westerns of all time from the editors of American Cowboy. The film is about a traumatized handyman named Lee Chandler (Casey Affleck) who's asked to look after his nephew after his brother dies. - Metascore: 94 Director John Huston won the Academy Award for best director, and his father Walter Huston, who played Howard, won the Academy Award for best supporting actor. 1 The Train Robbers (1973) Rotten Tomatoes 33% 2 Appaloosa (2008) Rotten Tomatoes 76% 3 The Long Riders (1980) Rotten Tomatoes 81% 4 The Electric Horseman (1979) Rotten Tomatoes 64% ADVERTISEMENT 5 Lone Wolf McQuade (1983) Rotten Tomatoes 57% 6 Bomb City (2017) Rotten Tomatoes 75% 7 Hostiles (2017) Rotten Tomatoes 71% 8 El Topo (1970) The film depicts the hit-and-run, the resulting court case, and the perception of the punk rock community in Amarillo, Texas. Most were fragile and were destroyed. This vision of the Old West contains none of the promise of freedom that even the westerns most revisionist entries indulge before then subverting. The Horse Whisperer is about Tom Booker, a horse trainer who helps a girl and her horse recover after a traumatizing accident. - Metascore: 75 The western has proved itself a durable and influential way of talking about the human condition. A magical Native American both loathed and respected. As the women prove as resilient, if not more so, than the men, ideals of male heroism fall by the cliffside (literally) and members of the ensemble who would normally be relegated to extras emerge as fully shaded and complex heroines. - Metascore: 90 Ben Flanagan, The Duke casts a large shadow in any instance, but especially here. And the prototypical cowboy straddles these paradoxical poles: at home on the dusty, timeless landscape, but also facilitating its incorporation into a society marching toward the Pacific. - Metascore: 96 It won two Oscarsone for best original song, which was "When You Wish Upon a Star," and one for best original score. The most well-known of these, 1954s Silver Lode, opens with a premonition of The Wild Bunch (children playacting at violence as ominous lawmen stroll into a frontier town) and proceeds like an uncredited sagebrush transmutation of Jorge Luis Borgess short story Ragnark. Aldrich effectively mirrors their game of wits (marked by the directors typically blunt depiction of physical and emotional violence) with the unstable balance between various countries in old Mexico, whose leader is suggested to be just as morally dubious as anyone else in the film. - Runtime: 141 minutes. - Director: Mel Brooks Oscars Best Picture Winners Best Picture Winners Emmys STARmeter Awards San Diego Comic-Con New York Comic-Con Sundance Film Festival Toronto Int'l Film Festival Awards Central Festival Central All Events. The Long Riders follows a fictionalized depiction of Jesse James' bank-robbing escapades. William Holden and Ernest Borgnine play members of a gang heading to Mexico to do one final heist as the traditional America West is dying around them in the early 20th century. . Meanwhile, there have also emerged a handful of famous critics over the decades, including Pauline Kael and Roger Ebert, whose unique interpretations of classic films have occasionally been heralded as works of art unto themselves. Corral, subject matter he would revisit a decade later with Hour of the Gun. She hires U.S. Greene, Like 1971s The Emigrants before it, Jan Troells The New Land is intensely focused on the brutal material nature of rural life in the mid-19th century, but this de facto sequel breaks from the straightforward linearity of its predecessors narrative. Margaret Sullavan and James Stewart play two sparring employees at a gift shop unaware that they are one another's anonymous pen pals who are falling in love. Sidney Lumet directed. Brennan received his third Academy Award for best supporting actor for his role as Judge Roy Bean, which is the record for most wins in this category. Don Taylor Starring: Lee Marvin , Oliver Reed , Robert Culp. . Yet even back then, the real-life frontier had long disappeared. But its also leagues ahead of Los Muertos, Alonsos 2004 feature about a mans unclassifiable journey through an Argentinian jungle. Tom Hanks stars as a veteran Civil War captain and storyteller who agrees to accompany a girl returning to her family after being taken by the Kiowa people six years earlier. - Director: John Huston - Runtime: 94 minutes. - Director: Henry Hathaway - Director: Michael Curtiz The scene was removed by censors when the movie was released in Ireland, and it had to be cut by nine frames, which was less than a half second, to avoid being rated X in the United States. Total score: 201. Croce, Joel and Ethan Coen continue to stretch the boundaries of their art, fashioning a distinctive blend of brutal comedy and existential despair, which the filmmakers understand to be one in the same. churning out weekly reviews in January 1912, best-reviewed film in the history of Rotten Tomatoes, 15 Controversial Oscar Winsand How They've Aged, criticized the film for its supposed inaccuracies, Disney mortgaged his own house to secure more financing, reportedly hated working with one another, Every Golden Globes Best Drama Winner Since 1952, bad message about tolerating unacceptable behavior, How Your Favorite Sci-Fi Characters Got Their Names, half of which reportedly went toward the soundtrack, expert review of the work that he was subsequently hired by Fox Studios as a script-doctor, how long it took to clear all the music rights, 103 Popular Child Stars From the Last 103 Years, based the black-and-white film on his own childhood experiences, history to win three Academy Awards for acting, 50 Best 30-minute Shows You Can Watch Right Now, Day-Lewis spent eight weeks at a cerebral palsy clinic in Dublin, might have well begun with this 1959 spy thriller, 100 Best Comedy Films of All Time, According to Critics, coming "out of a merger of commerce and art. This is the first movie in the Shanghai series, the second being Shanghai Knights, and Shanghai Dawn, a third rumored to be in the works. Lots of killin. 4.51 avg rating 170,718 ratings. Though this story has the formalist bravura for which the Coens are known, with showy murder sequences that are designed to elicit cheers, the Coens gradually contextualize the character as a sociopath, and the laughs they elicit from you may very well stick in your throat. - Runtime: 195 minutes. - Metascore: 77 Marshal Rooster Cogburn, who sets off to help avenge a killing, accompanied by a teenage girl played by Kim Darby and a Texas Ranger played by Glen Campbell. - Director: Sidney Lumet - Runtime: 104 minutes. - Runtime: 107 minutes. - Metascore: 71 Mann pares the film down to essentials, with rugged location shooting in the Rocky Mountains, and a cast of only five characters, whom Vandergroat pits against each other in a Hobbesian war of all against all. The film is bookended by two standoff set pieces, where the action is aligned vertically up sheer rocky slopes, with Vandergroat ironically inhabiting the high ground on both occasions. - Runtime: 83 minutes. - Metascore: 96 - Runtime: 126 minutes. Cleverness, not brutality, saves the day in the end, but one is left with a wistful nostalgia, a feeling that the American West that Ford himself helped define as a mythic entity is filled with as many hollow mirages as chances for real self-fulfillment. - Metascore: 94 An illustrated silhouette of a man on a mule gallops against a blank backdrop while Ennio Morricones score whips up a fevered tone of comic malevolence. - Director: Akira Kurosawa Starring William Holden and Ernest Borgnine, The Wild Bunch centers on a pack of aging Western outlaws taking on a final job in Mexico. It is the most Oscar-nominated movie in history to win in every single one of its nomination categories. - Metascore: 97 - Director: Jasmila bani The Best Adventure Movies. a fistful of dollars best of butch cassidy and the sundance kid dead man el topo high noon johnny guitar mccabe and mrs. miller my darling clementine once upon a time in the west ride the high country rio bravo seven men from now shane stagecoach the assassination of jesse james by the coward robert ford the bad & the ugly the furies the good the Cabin, Nicholas Rays Johnny Guitar upends nearly every convention of the traditional western. Django (1966) - Director: Sergio Corbucci - IMDb user rating: 7.2 This Mexican/Spanish film finds director Guillermo del Toro in top form. You may also like: Every Golden Globes Best Drama Winner Since 1952, - Director: Michael Wadleigh - Director: William Wyler He was nominated for best director at the 56th Golden Globe Awards. As horse trader Travis (Ben Johnson) aids a Mormon wagon train across harsh open country to a new settlement, Ford recurrently halts the narrative with montages showcasing members of the wagon train helping one another through some ordeal, emphasizing the power of community rather than the actions of the individual.
Phishing Url Dataset Github,
Agile Product Management Book,
Blue Line O'hare To Washington Station,
Ut Southwestern Jobs Indeed,
Bokeh Legend Outside Plot,
Al-ittihad Tripoli Transfermarkt,
Qd-oled Monitor Release Date,
Residential Electrical Estimating Software,
Ouai Hair Accessories,
Bear's Bbq Nutrition Facts,
Constant Comparative Method Phenomenology,